Oh, Bob... settle down... Cranky old bastard. :widemouthfrom previous experience in running a blind tasting....... DO NOT COMMIT TO DOING THIS UNLESS YOU CAN AND WILL SMOKE ALL OF THE CIGARS!!!
Oh, Bob... settle down... Cranky old bastard. :widemouthfrom previous experience in running a blind tasting....... DO NOT COMMIT TO DOING THIS UNLESS YOU CAN AND WILL SMOKE ALL OF THE CIGARS!!!
This. But I think I can trust these guys!from previous experience in running a blind tasting....... DO NOT COMMIT TO DOING THIS UNLESS YOU CAN AND WILL SMOKE ALL OF THE CIGARS!!!
Scotts new years resolution was to only smoke pole for 2012...so cigars are otta the question:grinFU:How on earth did you avoid getting involved in this?????????
I just about spit my coffee on my keyboard from that one...Scotts new years resolution was to only smoke pole for 2012...so cigars are otta the question:grinFU:
Forgot about that my bad.Scotts new years resolution was to only smoke pole for 2012...so cigars are otta the question:grinFU:
It may be a "C" in your book but to me it's more like batting .700 !! :grinFU: This will be fun to watch, something tells me that Mike has a curve ball up his sleeve.Man just making a statement like that tells me you would probably get about a C(70%)
Was thinking of sending five Fuente "It's a boy" and five "It's a Girl" without bands and having them pick which one is which.Actually, Mike's just gonna send Fuentes out to everyone...
just have to identify them as brevas, or identify if they were "boy" or "girl"? now THAT would be a task.Was thinking of sending five Fuente "It's a boy" and five "It's a Girl" without bands and having them pick which one is which.
Yeah, I was trying to be funny. Fail.or identify if they were "boy" or "girl"? now THAT would be a task.
Asleep at the wheel. Would have been cool but I ain't no party crasher. Life is messing with me again. SOB.How on earth did you avoid getting involved in this?????????
Sry to hear buddy, I hope everything will sort it self out for you.. Life is messing with me again. SOB.
Sorry guys, wasn't following the thread there for a couple days.I'll pass on this and let someone else have a little fun with it. Besides, it's too easy, there are more senses than just taste that will give the CC away. There's touch, sight and the barnyard smell. What about the caps, you gonna cut them off?
This will be fun to watch play out, if you want to expand it I'm sure there are a bunch of BOTL that would love to pick out a few sticks from their stash to send to a couple of guys, myself included.
I think it is possible to fool most people, specially if you are picking out sticks that you know will make it much harder.
I hope and guess that if the cigar are stored in my humidors I should be able to make a pretty accurate guess. For the the big difference is balance wich I think most Cubans have. But I don't think I would be able to guess right if it is a marca I don't like and have little experience in.
I love Cuban vintage. That said I have had very few ncs with over 10-15 years on them but there was a huge difference. So I think one has to give the cigars time to settle to be able to judge them properly and with time one can feel how different they are.
I think you will find very few people that say the can guess 100%. The more I learn about ccs do more I understand how little I know!
Dave can't tell a Blunt from a Garcia VegaLol!!! On second thought, I'm with Ben on this one!!!
I'm supremely confident that I could identify with perfect accuracy all of the cigars you send me with at least 20 years of age on them. PM for an addy to send all of your 20+ year old CC/NC samples, and dprice and I will get right on 'em! :headroll:
Lol!!! On second thought, I'm with Ben on this one!!!
I'm supremely confident that I could identify with perfect accuracy all of the cigars you send me with at least 20 years of age on them. PM for an addy to send all of your 20+ year old CC/NC samples, and dprice and I will get right on 'em! :headroll:
Weird! I had exactly the same resolution!Jokes have a tendency to go sideways here. Just saying. Good thing for you my new years resolution was to take all aggression out on Cmac
I see what you did there. :hystericaLol!!! On second thought, I'm with Ben on this one!!!
I'm supremely confident that I could identify with perfect accuracy all of the cigars you send me with at least 20 years of age on them. PM for an addy to send all of your 20+ year old CC/NC samples, and dprice and I will get right on 'em! :headroll: