Whats your favorite (most consistent) cigar

[pbibby]

Only stick I've never had a bad one of is Padron. So damn consistent

 

[CalixtoLopez]

Mine is the LADC Mi Amor.

By the way, the 2013 Oliva V Maduros are out. So good! This year in Dbl Robusto size

 

[MUNKY]

Dpg cc

 

[sdlaird]

Padron 2000 maduro. Go to.

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2

 

[CasualStogie]

+1 for padron


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Master Shake]

Whenever I have a couple sticks in a row that disappoint and I need something that I know is gonna be great and won't let me down then I always reach for the Oliva V Melanio PC. Always great, always consistent and always satisfies. Some might say the small size is a drawback but for me it is a plus because if I'm pinched for time its gonna be great or if I have a shitty first stick then I can correct the night with one of these.

 

[joshthe6th]

Cremo Classic Intrepidus (I reviewed it, and loved it so much I joined the company)

Cain F Double Toro

Alec Bradley MAXX

Oliva Serie V Torpedo

Fuente 8-5-8 Flor Fina natural (first cigar I had and loved it)

Onyx Reserve (got me into maduros)

CAO Italia

Padron (most of them)

 

[smokinbodybuilder]

La Sirena Sea Sprite

 

[Chief StrongLeaf]

Tat regios reserva

 

[ENV]

Quick question for those experienced guys in here. Are the 7-20-4 cigars consistent? I had what I believe was a Dogwalker size and it was OUTSTANDING. If these are consitent I would look to a box purchase one day.

 

[StogieNinja]

Quick question for those experienced guys in here. Are the 7-20-4 cigars consistent? I had what I believe was a Dogwalker size and it was OUTSTANDING. If these are consitent I would look to a box purchase one day.

I don't have experience across the whole line, but every dogwalker I've had has been consistent.

 

[sofc]

CF CG would be my one.

Once in a long while, a T52 or a #9 is not as flavorful as others. MF stuff is fantastic for construction and uniformity. I've had an Anejo or two I've MUed cause of flavor issues.

 

[HarleyMark13]

Liga's, Tat's and Padrons always hit the mark for me.

 

[ar2381]

Really like the LFD Factory Press IV. I am not sure if people consider it an everyday cigar, but I smoke it often at my local B&M. Also, a big fan of regularly smoking the LFD Colorado Oscuro and the Padron Thousand Series.

 

[scotchncigar]

Infused catagory would the DE Acid One, main catagory Oliva Reserve Connecticut, Herrera Esteli, DE Undercrown :ccool:

 

[blueboy714]

AF Hemingway (esp. Best Seller)
Oiva V (esp. Double Robusto)
Avo Domaine (esp. #40)
also a few CC

 

[Dread]

Quick question for those experienced guys in here. Are the 7-20-4 cigars consistent? I had what I believe was a Dogwalker size and it was OUTSTANDING. If these are consitent I would look to a box purchase one day.

Extremely consistent, I smoke plenty of them for obvious reasons and very rarely do I get one with imperfections.

 

[tedp]

Tat Brown Label Unicos
Tat Red Robo
LP40
Cigar factory of New Orleans Plantation

I know you asked for 1 but any time that I don't want to take a chance of being disappointed I grab one of these!:smokingbo

 

[CWS]

Oliva V - One of my primary go to cigars. Always consistent.
Fausto - My big bang cigar. Great flavor and strength
Tatuaje PCR - Never lets me down.

Runner up
T52 - Love this cigar. Pricey for a regular smoke but in the weekly rotation when I can get them

 

[pbibby]

Bolivar Petite Corona. 60% of the time, it works every time.