Tatuaje, DPG, and Oliva for me. I really love the Illusione's Epernay, but I can't put it up in the top three due to Illusione's constant construction problems. Fuente is a very close fourth.
My favorites are the Tat Red Tubos and Brown Label SW's, DPG's My Father Limited Editions, and Oliva Serie V Belicoso's.
I believe Viaje could move into my top three if they weren't so exclusive and hard to get. There regular line stuff is decent. Drew Estate could move up as well if they keep up the good work they started with the Liga Privada line.
I believe pedigree, consistency, and quality make great cigar makers. That's why I put Oliva, DPG, and Tat(Pete Johnson) at the top.