So far I have only found two tobaccos that I like enough to buy regularly. Escudo and Peterson's Old Dublin, but I won't buy anymore until I work my way through the ton of stuff that I currently have.
Right now i'm smoking through a tin of H&H Virginia Spice, which is pretty good but I just haven't mastered packing it yet so my experience has been a little inconsistent, but its tasty stuff. I still think I like Escudo better. But this Virginia Spice definitely has a more fuller heavier body to it. It has a touch of cigar leaf which I think helps.
I also have an open tin of Dan Pipe Midnight Ride. Nice but I still think I like Old Dublin better, it just smokes nicer for me. Stuff waiting in the wings:
Peterson Irish Whiskey
Sam Gawith Best Brown Flake
Orlik Golden Sliced
C&D Mississippi Mud
H&H Namaste
McClelland Wilderness from 2010