It's a matter of personal taste. The SW starts out so mild that I always wonder why I buy these things. Pretty quickly it ramps up to the mild/med range and the flavors start to emerge. It just continues to get more (and better) flavor as you smoke until it ends just past medium bodied. The Tainos starts great, has a great middle and a great end, but doesn't have the dynamic character of the SW. It is in the medium/full bodied range. I prefer the Tainos, but that's probably because that is what I've smoked most recently. Also, mine have a few years on them, so I have no opinion on current releases.
I have to agree about the RSW Maddie - best Tat ever! (Although, let me smoke some more Tenderloins and that may change).