When I first started out, I used a spreadsheet. Most of the guys I smoked with thought that was overkill, they saved the bands of what they liked. I tend to go a bit overboard when I do something and the spreadsheet just wasn't enough. I played around with a couple Access databases, even tried creating my own, but I just couldn't work it out the way I wanted. Late last year I came across StogieRate and figured I would give it a shot. For the most part, it has worked out for me. I am using version 4.2 (4.3 is available). You can provide your own rating, along with capturing notes. It also let you track age, cost per cigar, and other details. While you can add an image of the band, it is from a set list linked to their website. I haven't played around to see if you can pull an image from a local folder. I am interested to see how the reviews come back on the other apps before I spend the time on doing the upgrade!