Underwhelmed by A.J.?
- Thread starter leonthebum
- Start date
coastalgriff
Educated Redneck
Big fan of the DUC, MOWR and the LHCOF. Regardless of the price point they are tasty. I did not care for the Casa fernandez that much.
I've enjoyed the MoW and Diesel blends, as well.
I think each of us could list a brand or manufacturer that most everyone else likes and we don't. In fact, I'm even embarrassed to list mine - it would start a big argument!
I think each of us could list a brand or manufacturer that most everyone else likes and we don't. In fact, I'm even embarrassed to list mine - it would start a big argument!
Great cigar, especially if can be found for $2 each.
njstone
BoM January 2010
CI, Ccom, and Cbid OWN those blends, so of course they will rave about them.
That said, I have yet to try an AJ blend that I haven't liked, though I've not tried the new ones. The Ruination is fantastic, imvho.
That said, I have yet to try an AJ blend that I haven't liked, though I've not tried the new ones. The Ruination is fantastic, imvho.
njstone
BoM January 2010
I agree that some of his cheaper smokes taste "cheap" in the sense that they don't use high-quality tobacco. But they taste great for cheap cigars, to me at least. The exception is the Ruination which uses pretty good leaf, imvho. I haven't had any of the newer blends, though.
Docbp87
Smoke Into Oblivion
If I never saw any of the BS hype that CI/CCom give this guy, I would probably think he was a pretty good blender, since there are a few of his cigars that I think are pretty darn good (Diesel UC, MOW, and MOW Ruination), but there is just so much bargain basement bin junk that he makes, for various brands, and especially the CI/CCom exclusive stuff... that just sucks. Am I underwhelmed, eh... no, but that's because I've learned to take the CI marketing for what it is.
A single cigar taught me a valuable lesson about CI - Devil's Weed.
I bought their bundle of 24 for $24.99, back when I was just starting to smoke, and they pimped it out as some ridiculous, amazing deal on SUPER PREMIUM CIGARS that you'll never see again in your life and if you pass it up you'll regret it so much you'll probably burn your house down with you inside it.
And man...those cigars are ass. They're ugly, burn terribly, and taste like burnt toast and grass.
So yeah...CI is certainly deceptive in that they just want to sell you anything you'll buy - every single cigar in their catalogue is "scrumptious" or "delectable"
That being said, they do have some good prices, and I've got some GREAT deals from the Jam.
But back to the topic at hand - AJ - I definitely think his Diesel and Man o' War labels are his crowning achievements. And that's nothing to bat an eye at, because they're great smokes.
Personally not a fan.
By the way, someone mentioned Casa Fernandez being blended by him, that is not correct.
By the way, someone mentioned Casa Fernandez being blended by him, that is not correct.
im very hit or miss with AJ. a few blend i like very much, (most of the MoW line especially the Armada) but some of them i dont like very much like much of the lower end stuff. there is a cheap taste to many of them. The Diesel line just doesnt have the complexity i want out of it. i dont think its supposed to.
The San Lotano line is simply awesome. This is AJ's own line and I believe it is only sold to retailers right now. Most people I know who have had them - LOVE THEM. The Connecticut is a wonderful surprise. It was my favorite of the three blends released. I had it ranked #8 for 2010.
Last edited:
I think the most of his stuff is just average at best. only like the disel and MOW everything else is just bargin basement stuff. As said before CI just hypes this guy up to be on the same level as DPG.
