Gonna go w/ a big +1 on this as well...Guess we're a little spoiled on the Rogue front here, but I've actually grown to resent them a little. There's no way Dead guy, and Shakespeare stout, and Rogues other regular releases ought to be selling for $7+ per 22, when other local-ish breweries (Ninkasi, 10 barrels, Lagunitas, Laughing Dog, Deschutes etc.) can be had for $4-$5. Gotta look out for the local folk who supported you 15+ years ago.:argue:
-Dude
(End spoiled tantrum)
I don't reach for Rogue anymore when in the stores...but I wouldn't hesitate to pick em' up at the garage sale you mentioned. Prices at those events are crazy good! A buddy of mine and I split about 5-6 cases on different stuff last year from their Newport Brewery, and I'd do that again in a heartbeat.
As you mentioned though....their prices are a little higher, and there's just plain better stuff on the shelves here locally. A lot come across to me as lighter in flavor, and maybe just more "watered down" is how I'd best describe it.
My favorite Rogues have been the Chocolate Stout, Dead Guy (as an every day drinker), and the Captain Sig Northwestern Ale.
And sometimes, especially when it comes to beer/cigars, it's good to be spoiled! :grin: